Striking a Balance
So, if not a single additional student registers in one of my classes for fall, I’ll still have 142 students in my three courses.
Of course, I’m guaranteed to have more students register. Other courses on the books will be cancelled, causing a cascade effect that will surely send at least a dozen more my way and we can’t forget that a large number of first year students have yet to register.
This isn’t the largest total enrollment that I’ve ever faced, but the last time numbers soared much higher than this, I nearly collapsed under the heavy load of marking. You see, I have this funny notion that history is best taught through student writing, and a fair bit of it. But when I have eighty students already enrolled in my ancient Near East survey course, how can I keep my marking scheme including ten tutorials, a short essay, a midterm and a longer essay, as well as a final exam? (With eighty students, the conservative outcome is 2000 pages of student work to mark. Gah!)
The wise answer is, “I can’t.” But I still haven’t come up with a really awesome answer to the old marking scheme dilemma. I think I have an answer for the first year class where I’ve concentrated the formal writing assignments on steps toward a final research project and settled on eight tutorials with responses.
I’m not sure what to do with the ANE class given that I’ve already ordered The Epic of Gilgamesh with intentions of using that for a first, shorter essay assignment. And if I don’t have some sort of tutorial quiz or response that’s marked, students rarely do the tutorial readings or participate. But maybe ten tutorials in the term are overkill?
So, do I drop the free-choice essay for the end of the course (an assignment that’s problematic seeing as many students will want to write on Greco-Roman issues which are outside the purview of the course while a few others will try to plagiarize) and bump the Gilgamesh essay to later in the term (and increase its scope somewhat so that students can draw on course-long themes or make comparative arguments)? I can’t easily be comfortable in a course where there’s no research-based composition of some sort or another, so dropping the essays entirely doesn’t seem like a good idea.
What about testing (which can be marked with much more ease than any composition assignments)? Do I stick with one midterm as I’ve tentatively planned or go for two quizzes (at the end of each month)? Or maybe drop every test but the university-mandated final exam?
I’ll be wrestling with this course plan for some weeks, I fear. Stay tuned!
Comments(5)